TechWeb

Office 365: 7 Missing Features For Enterprises

Jun 28, 2011 (10:06 AM EDT)

Read the Original Article at http://www.informationweek.com/news/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=231000630


Microsoft CEO Steve Ballmer formally introduced Office 365 on Tuesday at an event in New York City. The service is a rebranded, upgraded version of the company's Business Productivity Online Standard suite that adds Office Web Apps and other cloud services.

With new collaboration tools like Lync and SharePoint Online, and Web-based versions of staples like Word, Excel, and PowerPoint, Office 365 should give Google a run in the market for productivity tools that live in the cloud. Still, some omissions and weaknesses could hamper its take-up in the enterprise market. Here's what's missing.

1. Fully functional Web apps. Despite Microsoft's marketing pitch, Office 365 isn't really "Office In The Cloud." Not entirely, anyway. The cloud-based versions of Word, Excel, and PowerPoint offer only a subset of the functionality of their desktop versions. For instance, the Office Web Apps version of PowerPoint doesn’t have the high-performance video editing tools found in the desktop version, and OWA Word is good for only "light editing," according to Microsoft.

This limited functionality is, of course, by design. With the client version of Office still accounting for about one-third of annual revenue, Microsoft has a strong incentive to keep users on the desktop for the full Office experience. The company notes that Office Web Apps are great for viewing, storing, and sharing documents. But given the numerous online storage products already available for free or at very low cost, many organizations may conclude that the setup hassles for Office 365 won't be worth it unless the software is fully functional.

Office 365 Vs. Google Apps: Top 10 Enterprise Concerns
Office 365 Vs. Google Apps: Top 10 Enterprise Concerns
(click image for larger view and forslideshow)
2. Pricing flexibility. Subscription-based software is like the rent-to-own furniture business: It's great for customers who don't want to spend a lot of money up front, but from an economic standpoint, renting can be a lousy decision. The full-on enterprise edition of Office 365 is priced at $27 per user, per month. That's $324 per year, every year. An outright purchase of Office Professional requires a one-time payment of $499 (less volume discounts), about 18 months worth of Office 365, and it's yours forever. Microsoft would note that the Office 365 subscription includes collaboration tools, support, and access to the latest upgrades. But for many organizations, the math may still not work. Microsoft needs to offer a basic version of Office 365 available for a one-off payment for businesses that don't need the high-level support and ongoing updates.

3. Backwards compatibility. Isn't cloud computing supposed to remove the headaches of constantly maintaining and upgrading software on the desktop? Then why does Office 365 require users to have new or almost new versions of Windows and other products running locally in order to access the online suite? The oldest version of Windows that will support Office 365 is Windows XP, Service Pack 3. Mac users will need at least OS X 10.5 or later. For Web access, users will need Internet Explorer 7 or later. On Macs, only Safari 3 or later will do. Also note that Office 365 doesn’t support Outlook 2003 or earlier versions. Again, it gets back to the fact that Microsoft, unlike Google, isn't fully committed to the cloud because it still depends on desktop and server products for the bulk of its revenue. That means it will need its customers to upgrade—constantly. Until that reality changes, Microsoft's cloud offerings, including Office 365, will have that "neither fish-nor-fowl" aspect about them.

4. Enterprise-class support and uptime. If Office 365 is to succeed, it needs to offer a more dependable experience than what BPOS users received. BPOS was Microsoft's first cloud-based office platform, and it showed. The service suffered from frequent interruptions, and support could be spotty. Just last month, the BPOS email service was hit with disruptions and admins were left in the dark as their service dashboards also went offline. Some users have also complained about subpar and hard-to-reach technical support arising from the fact that some BPOS helpdesk functions were outsourced to India.

For Office 365, Microsoft is adopting a multitenant service architecture that should solve some of the problems. It's also guaranteeing 99.9% uptime. It has to deliver. CIOs who put their reputations on the line with an Office 365 implementation won't tolerate anything less than rock solid performance.




5. True multi-platform access. Microsoft says Office 365 lets users work "from virtually anywhere and nearly any device with a familiar productivity experience across PC, phone, and browser." But blogosphere reports indicate that the cross-platform vision is more promise than reality.

iPad users who downloaded the trial version of Office 365 reported a number of problems. "I can't edit any document on the application," complained one, on a board maintained by iPadForums.net. Communicator for Mac 2011 also doesn't work. Furthermore, Office 365 performance isn’t consistent across Microsoft's own line of products. Office Web Apps exhibit different features and functionality depending on whether they're accessed on the desktop, tablets, or mobile devices. "There are some differences," Microsoft concedes.

Isn't the cloud supposed to enable a uniform, consistent end-user experience regardless of device? Microsoft needs to address this issue, or it could send the millions of iPad-using workers who need a solid office experience straight to Google.

6. In-document collaboration. Office 365 lets colleagues view and share documents through SharePoint and Lync Online. But when it comes to collaborating within a document, via real-time, simultaneous authoring, editing, and markup, Office 365 falls short. InformationWeek's side-by-side comparison of Office 365 and Google Apps gave Google the nod. This is inexplicable given the wealth of collaboration tools Microsoft gained through its acquisition of Ray Ozzie's Groove Networks in 2005. (Then again, Ozzie recently left the company after concluding Microsoft wasn't fully committed to the cloud.) Office 365's appeal in document-heavy industries like publishing, legal, and research could be limited until its collaboration capabilities are improved.

Office 365 Vs. Google Apps: Top 10 Enterprise Concerns
Office 365 Vs. Google Apps: Top 10 Enterprise Concerns
(click image for larger view and forslideshow)
7. Robust developer tools. What you see is what you get with Office 365 because there are few developer tools. "The main fly-in-the-ointment for developers is that there's no way your business users can make use of add-ins, VBA macros, or any form of customization unless they fall back on locally installed applications," says Kay Ewbank of the "I Programmer" blog. That means possibilities for integrating Office 365 with other business apps or creating customized workflows are limited. With the next update to Office 365, Microsoft needs to focus on the developer.

The bottom line: Office 365 is the first step in what inevitably will be Microsoft's full migration to the cloud. The software industry is headed that way whether Redmond likes it or not. But the company's financial dependence on desktop and server software means its journey could take longer than legacy-free rivals. Office 365 is a solid product for businesses that want to take a similarly cautious road to the cloud. Less patient travelers may find it lacking.

Virtual Event: Business Mobility Unleashed. Zero in on the top mobile technologies and techniques to ensure your organization thrives in the wireless world. Learn about strategies and products that offer remote user applications support, Wi-Fi management, security features, and device management. Our virtual event happens Thursday, July 14. Register now.